An Oklahoma City woman who voted twice in the 2024 statewide General Election pleaded guilty earlier this month.
The Oklahoma State Election Board discovered Victoria Vincenza Dill, 32, voted in person in Oklahoma County and submitted an absentee ballot in Payne County on Nov. 5, 2024. Consequently, she was indicted Oct. 9, 2025, by the 21st Multicounty Grand Jury on a charge of voting illegally.
The general election ballot included president/vice president, state leaders such as corporation commissioner, U.S. representatives, state senators and representatives, judges, and state questions.
Title 26, Section 16-102 of the Oklahoma Statutes decrees, “Any person who votes more than once at any election … shall be deemed guilty of a felony.”
District Judge Jason Reese gave Dill a five-year deferred prison sentence on May 8 and placed her under court supervision for the next two years. Reese also ordered Dill to pay a $150 fine to Payne County, a $50 Victim Compensation Assessment, and $434 in court costs. In addition, she is now ineligible to register to vote.
Besides Dill, 38 other potential violations of state election laws – including 26 other suspected instances of double voting – also were reported during that election. It is not known whether criminal charges were filed in any of those cases.
A dozen other alleged voting crimes occurred during the November 2024 General Election, State Election Board spokesperson Misha Mohr told Southwest Ledger. “This may not be a comprehensive list,” she said. “However, these are the alleged crimes that were reported to the appropriate district attorney, the attorney general, or the U.S. Attorney.”
Those incidents included:
•Possible double voter: Cleveland County (15 cases), Canadian County (five), Carter County (two instances), and Tulsa, Creek, Major and McIntosh counties (one instance each). “Many times, ‘double voters’ are elderly citizens who don’t remember submitting their absentee ballots and show up at the polls on Election Day to vote,” Mohr said.
•Potential voter registration violation: Canadian County (two instances) and McIntosh County (one).
•Application for absentee ballot submitted by an alleged felon: Dewey County (one). State Statutes, Title 26, Section 102.2, states that, “Any person who knowingly executes a false application for an absentee ballot shall be deemed guilty of a felony.”
•Alleged felon voter: Washington County (two instances) and Creek County (one). Title 26, Section 16-102, states, “Any person who, “knowing that he or she is not eligible to vote at an election, willfully votes at said election, shall be deemed guilty of a felony.”
•Possible noncitizen registration: Oklahoma County (three applicants). “I am not sure when these voter registration applications were submitted; however, letters were sent to the appropriate authorities” last November and December, Mohr said. Title 26, Section 103, states, “Any person who knowingly swears or affirms a false affidavit in order to become eligible to vote” has committed a felony offense.
•Noncitizen excused from jury duty: Texas and Garfield counties (one each). “These registered voters were identified as noncitizens after being excused from jury duty as noncitizens,” Mohr said. “Again, I am not sure when these voter registration applications were submitted; however, letters were sent to the appropriate authorities in October and December 2024.”
Voter ‘fraud’ cases are mere fraction of total votes cast
The 39 suspected voting offenses reported in Oklahoma in the 2024 General Election constituted 25 ten-thousandths of 1 percent of the 1,566,173 votes cast in the Presidential election, the contest that received the most votes.
After the Oklahoma State Election Board reviewed information it received from Oklahoma’s 77 county election boards, the total number of voter irregularities detected during the November 2020 statewide General Election was set at 66, Mohr said.
They included a couple of reported cases in Payne County in which absentee ballots were returned by persons other than the voters themselves, contrary to state law.
Elsewhere in the state, Oklahoma County reported 19 cases of voter fraud; Tulsa County, eight cases; Pittsburg and Muskogee counties, four cases each; Cleveland, Delaware and Okmulgee counties, two cases each; and Grady, Mayes, Osage and Sequoyah counties, one case each.
“All of these alleged crimes involved voters who voted twice, unless otherwise noted,” Mohr said Those 66 incidents constituted .0042% of the 1.566 million votes cast in the 2020 Presidential race – 42 ten-thousandths of 1 percent.
Post-election audits have consistently proven that Oklahoma elections are safe and secure, State Election Board Secretary Paul Ziriax has said repeatedly. “The accuracy of Oklahoma election results has been confirmed, time and time again, through both manual post-election audits and candidate-requested recounts.”
Post-election audits were enacted by the state Legislature and implemented by the State Election Board in 2022 “for the purpose of maintaining the security of the election system…” Post-elections audits are defined as “a manual or electronic examination of a limited number of ballots.”